______________________________________________________________________

                             ACM-SE 2001
                           REFEREE'S REPORT
______________________________________________________________________

INSTRUCTIONS: Download form from Web (it's plain text) and using your
              favorite editor replace the text within '<' '>'.
              Then e-mail the file back to 'seacm@cs.uga.edu'.
______________________________________________________________________

A. PAPER IDENTIFICATION

NUMBER  __ <R.99> __

TITLE   __ <Imperfections in Modern Counting Processes> __

AUTHORS __ <James A. Baker et al.> __

______________________________________________________________________

Please rate paper in each of the following four categories.
Rating Scale: Excellent (A), Good (B), Fair (C), or Unsuitable (D).
IMPORTANT:    Remarks should include SUGGESTIONS FOR IMPROVEMENT.
______________________________________________________________________

B. TECHNICAL QUALITY ASSESSMENT (A-D)                        __ <A> __

   REMARKS: Accuracy, Technical Correctness, Literature Discussed, etc.

   <use as much space as needed>

______________________________________________________________________

C. PRESENTATION QUALITY ASSESSMENT (A-D)                     __ <B> __

   REMARKS: Organization, Clarity, Style, Wording, Illustrations, etc.

   <use as much space as needed>

______________________________________________________________________

D. INTEREST, RELEVANCE (A-D)                                 __ <C> __

   REMARKS: Topical Area within CS/CE/IS, Level of Interest, etc. 

   <use as much space as needed>

______________________________________________________________________

E. ORIGINALITY (A-D)                                         __ <D> __

   REMARKS: Novelty, Creativity, etc.

   <use as much space as needed>

______________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________

F. RANKING (Student Paper Competition Only)                  __ <5> __

   [Best (5), Second (4), Third (3), Fourth (2), Fifth (1), Lower (0)]

______________________________________________________________________